From ‘us’ to ‘other’ – The hidden cost of organizational change

Column by Richard Randall

Nothing defines your culture, or you as a leader, more than the way you treat people. When you are the leader of an organization, the people you lead watch everything you do. They are tough critics, and they can smell hypocrisy a mile away. They take their cues from your behavior, not from your words. When you tell your people what your values are, you set the bar they will use to evaluate your actions. 

It’s great to work in a culture with strong values like integrity, stewardship, kindness and respect. I’ve had the good fortune to work in cultures like that. When you are the leader who walks the talk in a culture like that you get high marks from your people. You get your reward when they respond to your leadership by giving their best at work. They have your back.

Yet over the years I’ve seen cracks in this ideal –many situations where good people have not been treated well in seemingly good cultures. I’m beginning to believe it has something to do with how leaders compartmentalize people and how that shapes their treatment of them.

Richard Randall

I once witnessed a corporate restructuring in a company that had built up a lot of goodwill by treating people the right way. But when the restructuring happened, everyone who was being let go seemed to be treated as no longer part of “us.” They became “other.”

I was told to deliver the news to a friend of 20 years because our boss wanted to leave early for headquarters. When I objected, he said he’d do it over the phone. That felt inhumane, so I gritted my teeth and did it myself. I can never forget that discussion.

Word spread pretty fast about that and about a number of other people who were unceremoniously shown the door after long and successful careers. The company preached the same values it had always had, but the treatment of those people resonated and that culture was never the same. The respect for leadership was lost.

A friend recently related an event from her career. She had given two weeks’ notice to her employer. During those two weeks, the person who had been her closest supervisor never made eye contact with her or thanked her for her time with the company. I think the minute she gave her notice she became “other.” Imagine what her coworkers thought when they witnessed that behavior.

I started this column by saying nothing defines your culture, or you as a leader, more than the way you treat people.  Whether it’s a layoff, a restructuring, a termination due to performance or a voluntary resignation, there’s never an excuse for not treating people the right way. Your people are watching your behavior and discussing your behavior. As a leader, your actions in difficult moments define your legacy. Let your people see, and feel, your integrity.


Richard Randall is founder and president of management consulting firm New Level Advisors in Springettsbury Township, York County. Email him at [email protected].

Executives Insights is a recurring feature from biznewsPA that provides local business executives and leaders a platform for sharing advice and perspective with the business community of Central Pennsylvania. If you are interested in contributing an executive insight, email [email protected].

Column by Richard Randall

Nothing defines your culture, or you as a leader, more than the way you treat people. When you are the leader of an organization, the people you lead watch everything you do. They are tough critics, and they can smell hypocrisy a mile away. They take their cues from your behavior, not from your words. When you tell your people what your values are, you set the bar they will use to evaluate your actions. 

It’s great to work in a culture with strong values like integrity, stewardship, kindness and respect. I’ve had the good fortune to work in cultures like that. When you are the leader who walks the talk in a culture like that you get high marks from your people. You get your reward when they respond to your leadership by giving their best at work. They have your back.

Yet over the years I’ve seen cracks in this ideal –many situations where good people have not been treated well in seemingly good cultures. I’m beginning to believe it has something to do with how leaders compartmentalize people and how that shapes their treatment of them.

Richard Randall

I once witnessed a corporate restructuring in a company that had built up a lot of goodwill by treating people the right way. But when the restructuring happened, everyone who was being let go seemed to be treated as no longer part of “us.” They became “other.”

I was told to deliver the news to a friend of 20 years because our boss wanted to leave early for headquarters. When I objected, he said he’d do it over the phone. That felt inhumane, so I gritted my teeth and did it myself. I can never forget that discussion.

Word spread pretty fast about that and about a number of other people who were unceremoniously shown the door after long and successful careers. The company preached the same values it had always had, but the treatment of those people resonated and that culture was never the same. The respect for leadership was lost.

A friend recently related an event from her career. She had given two weeks’ notice to her employer. During those two weeks, the person who had been her closest supervisor never made eye contact with her or thanked her for her time with the company. I think the minute she gave her notice she became “other.” Imagine what her coworkers thought when they witnessed that behavior.

I started this column by saying nothing defines your culture, or you as a leader, more than the way you treat people.  Whether it’s a layoff, a restructuring, a termination due to performance or a voluntary resignation, there’s never an excuse for not treating people the right way. Your people are watching your behavior and discussing your behavior. As a leader, your actions in difficult moments define your legacy. Let your people see, and feel, your integrity.


Richard Randall is founder and president of management consulting firm New Level Advisors in Springettsbury Township, York County. Email him at [email protected].

Executives Insights is a recurring feature from biznewsPA that provides local business executives and leaders a platform for sharing advice and perspective with the business community of Central Pennsylvania. If you are interested in contributing an executive insight, email [email protected].

Share:

Gladly Sponsored By:

The main tool we use for the BizNewsPA newsletter is ActiveCampaign.

ActiveCampaign helps us manage our subscribers, build the newsletter, and schedule it for our bright and early release time.

If you think ActiveCampaign can help you and your business, click here.

More Central PA News

Food

Lancaster cookie startup plans bankruptcy filing

Lancaster-based cookie startup Taylor Chip said this week that it plans to file for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection after an unsuccessful bid to generate retail sales in Philadelphia. Due to the slow pace of permitting in the city, it took nearly 18 months longer than expected to open the stores, and they did not earn enough […]

To access this post, you must purchase biznewsPA Subscription or biznewsPA Team Subscriptions.

Read More »
Education

Harrisburg U stops bond payments while in talks to restructure debt

Harrisburg University of Science and Technology is pausing bond payments as it looks to restructure debt tied to a real estate investment that has yet to pan out. That would be the $100 million in bonds the university floated to pay for an 11-story health sciences building at 222 Chestnut St. The university said yesterday that […]

To access this post, you must purchase biznewsPA Subscription or biznewsPA Team Subscriptions.

Read More »
Manufacturing

Is a sale in the works for Steelton plant?

Executives at Cleveland-Cliffs said this week they have buyers for some of their idled plants, a group of assets that includes a massive factory in Steelton. On a conference call with stock analysts, company execs said they expect to generate $425 million from selling the idle plants — and that the Ohio-based steelmaker already closed on one deal […]

To access this post, you must purchase biznewsPA Subscription or biznewsPA Team Subscriptions.

Read More »
Health Care

WellSpan mini hospital poised to open

WellSpan Heath is preparing to admit the first patients to Newberry Hospital, the first of three mini hospitals being developed by the regional health system.  Located next to the Newberry Commons shopping center in Newberry Township, York County, the small-format hospital is set to open in early March, according to WellSpan leaders, who offered a behind-the-scenes look […]

To access this post, you must purchase biznewsPA Subscription or biznewsPA Team Subscriptions.

Read More »
Manufacturing

Metal fabricator adds space as demand takes off

When Brian Greenplate acquired Precision Cut Industries Inc. in 2004 the company had 25 employees and annual revenue of about $3 million Yearly sales for the contract metal fabricator have grown to about $50 million, and they are expected to jump again this year thanks to demand from customers in energy, commercial construction and data centers, […]

To access this post, you must purchase biznewsPA Subscription or biznewsPA Team Subscriptions.

Read More »
Government

Advocates renew push for statewide carbon limits

In November, the Shapiro administration agreed to drop controversial state rules curbing carbon emissions from large power plants in return for Senate passage of a delayed state budget. Three months later, environmentalists are pushing for an expanded version of the rules, arguing that the state’s failure to crack down on carbon pollution violates environmental protections […]

To access this post, you must purchase biznewsPA Subscription or biznewsPA Team Subscriptions.

Read More »