Subscribe to our newsletters!

Pennsylvania builds quietly. That’s costing our founders.

Column by Martin Fedorko

Pennsylvania builds companies in places that don’t look like startup towns. A bakery on Market Street in York. A donkey and horse stable in Winfield. A lab in State College. A shop in Erie that’s been running since the Depression. Once in a while, an actual garage.

Building them here isn’t the hard part, and it never has been. The hard part is that most of it happens without anybody outside the Commonwealth finding out it happened at all.

No two companies look alike

There’s no template for a Pennsylvania company. That’s the first thing you notice once you’ve looked at a few hundred of them.

Wove started on a deployment in Afghanistan. Drew Wolgemuth was an Army Ranger, and the guys in his platoon kept trying to buy engagement rings from a war zone, which went about as well as it sounds. So, he set up video calls between soldiers and jewelers and had 3D-printed replicas shipped over, so a guy could hold the ring in his hand before committing to it. When Wolgemuth got out he called another Ranger, Brian Elliot. They built the company in Lancaster, where Wolgemuth’s parents had run a jewelry shop for years. NPR did a segment on them in 2023.

Martin Fedorko

Phospholutions is 30  years of phosphorus research at Penn State turned into a fertilizer business. Croptix reads the light coming off a leaf to tell a grower a tree is sick before the tree looks sick. Gilson Snow is two middle school science teachers who moved into that stable in Winfield with 35 snowboards and an Airstream and now ship to more than 50 countries. The Pretzel Co. started hand-twisting on Market Street in York in 2014, and last November its gift box turned up on Oprah’s Favorite Things with “With Love, From York, PA” printed on the side. Bliley Technologies has been making frequency control components in Erie since around 1930. Kyocera bought the business in 2023 and then broke ground on a new plant in town.

A war zone, a research lab, an orchard, a stable, a bakery and a ninety-year-old machine shop. Same state. Not one of them got here the same way.

That variety is a pleasure to live inside and a problem to explain. Some states have one name that does the explaining for them, and when somebody says Austin or Boston the rest of the sentence isn’t necessary. Pennsylvania has never had a name like that, which means every conversation about what’s being built here has to start from scratch.

Nobody is coming to look

Different companies, different decades, different industries. Every one of them had to break out to get noticed.

And breaking out took something outsized. An NPR producer took an interest. A magazine editor put a box of pretzels on a list. An acquirer already knew the sector well enough to go looking in Erie.

That’s the bar as it stands. A Pennsylvania company doesn’t get seen for being good. It gets seen for being impossible to miss.

Nobody in New York or California wakes up in the morning wondering what’s for sale in central Pennsylvania. That isn’t a knock on them. Attention runs along channels that already exist, and for the most part those channels don’t run through here.

The mechanics are worth spelling out. An investor in San Francisco hears about a company because a founder they backed once makes the introduction, or because it came out of a program they follow, or because it’s 20  minutes away. Those three routes account for most of what gets funded in this country. For a lot of firms, Pennsylvania sits outside all three.

So, a company here can be excellent and still be invisible. And from a desk in Manhattan, invisible and nonexistent look about the same.

It isn’t only investors who stop finding you. A customer who would have bought the thing never hears it exists. An engineer who would have moved home for the right job never learns the job is open. A founder two counties over spends a year solving a problem somebody in this state already solved.

And the person least equipped to fix any of that is the founder. She has a product to ship and payroll to make, and telling the world about herself is the 11th item on a 10-item list. It also runs against the grain around here, where talking up your own company is considered a little impolite.

So, we raise our hand

The building side of this is in better shape than people give it credit for. Ben Franklin Technology Partners writes early checks. Penn State’s LaunchBoxes and the Center for Innovation and Entrepreneurship at Harrisburg University give founders a desk and somebody to ask. Incubators run from York to Erie. None of it is glamorous, and all of it works.

What’s thin is the telling. This is a state full of people who would rather build the thing than talk about it, and that instinct has cost our founders more than any funding gap ever has.

Getting named is not a vanity exercise. A company people have heard of closes its next customer faster. It recruits better, because a good engineer in Pittsburgh will return a call from a company they recognize. And when it goes out to raise, the fund across the table has seen the name somewhere before, which is worth more in a first meeting than any deck.

There’s a second effect that’s easy to miss. When a company here gets its due, the founder three towns over sees it and quietly recalculates what’s possible from where she’s sitting. That’s how a place starts producing more of them. Not from a program. From proof.

So, we’re going to do the talking. Over the next several weeks, Keystone Innovation Collaborative is publishing lists of Pennsylvania companies worth watching, sector by sector:

• Health and life sciences

• Advanced manufacturing

• Agricultural technology

• Energy technology

• Robotics and AI

Names, founders and the towns they’re building in. Some of those towns you’d expect. A lot of them you wouldn’t.

And if you’re building something here, tell us. We’d rather hear it from you now than find you a year from now.

If we want outside capital and national customers to look this way, somebody here has to say it loudly and then keep saying it. What’s being built in Pennsylvania is worth the trip.

The companies above aren’t unusual. Pennsylvania has been turning them out for a century, in bakeries and machine shops and stables and, at least once, on a base in Afghanistan.

This state has never struggled to build. It has struggled to be heard. That’s the work in front of us.


Martin Fedorko is managing partner of White Rose Ventures, a York-based venture capital firm focused on fueling early-stage innovation, and interim executive director of the Keystone Innovation Collaborative.

Executive Insights is a recurring feature from biznewsPA. It provides local business executives and leaders a platform for sharing advice and perspective with the business community of Central Pennsylvania. If you are interested in contributing an executive insight, email [email protected].

Column by Martin Fedorko

Pennsylvania builds companies in places that don’t look like startup towns. A bakery on Market Street in York. A donkey and horse stable in Winfield. A lab in State College. A shop in Erie that’s been running since the Depression. Once in a while, an actual garage.

Building them here isn’t the hard part, and it never has been. The hard part is that most of it happens without anybody outside the Commonwealth finding out it happened at all.

No two companies look alike

There’s no template for a Pennsylvania company. That’s the first thing you notice once you’ve looked at a few hundred of them.

Wove started on a deployment in Afghanistan. Drew Wolgemuth was an Army Ranger, and the guys in his platoon kept trying to buy engagement rings from a war zone, which went about as well as it sounds. So, he set up video calls between soldiers and jewelers and had 3D-printed replicas shipped over, so a guy could hold the ring in his hand before committing to it. When Wolgemuth got out he called another Ranger, Brian Elliot. They built the company in Lancaster, where Wolgemuth’s parents had run a jewelry shop for years. NPR did a segment on them in 2023.

Martin Fedorko

Phospholutions is 30  years of phosphorus research at Penn State turned into a fertilizer business. Croptix reads the light coming off a leaf to tell a grower a tree is sick before the tree looks sick. Gilson Snow is two middle school science teachers who moved into that stable in Winfield with 35 snowboards and an Airstream and now ship to more than 50 countries. The Pretzel Co. started hand-twisting on Market Street in York in 2014, and last November its gift box turned up on Oprah’s Favorite Things with “With Love, From York, PA” printed on the side. Bliley Technologies has been making frequency control components in Erie since around 1930. Kyocera bought the business in 2023 and then broke ground on a new plant in town.

A war zone, a research lab, an orchard, a stable, a bakery and a ninety-year-old machine shop. Same state. Not one of them got here the same way.

That variety is a pleasure to live inside and a problem to explain. Some states have one name that does the explaining for them, and when somebody says Austin or Boston the rest of the sentence isn’t necessary. Pennsylvania has never had a name like that, which means every conversation about what’s being built here has to start from scratch.

Nobody is coming to look

Different companies, different decades, different industries. Every one of them had to break out to get noticed.

And breaking out took something outsized. An NPR producer took an interest. A magazine editor put a box of pretzels on a list. An acquirer already knew the sector well enough to go looking in Erie.

That’s the bar as it stands. A Pennsylvania company doesn’t get seen for being good. It gets seen for being impossible to miss.

Nobody in New York or California wakes up in the morning wondering what’s for sale in central Pennsylvania. That isn’t a knock on them. Attention runs along channels that already exist, and for the most part those channels don’t run through here.

The mechanics are worth spelling out. An investor in San Francisco hears about a company because a founder they backed once makes the introduction, or because it came out of a program they follow, or because it’s 20  minutes away. Those three routes account for most of what gets funded in this country. For a lot of firms, Pennsylvania sits outside all three.

So, a company here can be excellent and still be invisible. And from a desk in Manhattan, invisible and nonexistent look about the same.

It isn’t only investors who stop finding you. A customer who would have bought the thing never hears it exists. An engineer who would have moved home for the right job never learns the job is open. A founder two counties over spends a year solving a problem somebody in this state already solved.

And the person least equipped to fix any of that is the founder. She has a product to ship and payroll to make, and telling the world about herself is the 11th item on a 10-item list. It also runs against the grain around here, where talking up your own company is considered a little impolite.

So, we raise our hand

The building side of this is in better shape than people give it credit for. Ben Franklin Technology Partners writes early checks. Penn State’s LaunchBoxes and the Center for Innovation and Entrepreneurship at Harrisburg University give founders a desk and somebody to ask. Incubators run from York to Erie. None of it is glamorous, and all of it works.

What’s thin is the telling. This is a state full of people who would rather build the thing than talk about it, and that instinct has cost our founders more than any funding gap ever has.

Getting named is not a vanity exercise. A company people have heard of closes its next customer faster. It recruits better, because a good engineer in Pittsburgh will return a call from a company they recognize. And when it goes out to raise, the fund across the table has seen the name somewhere before, which is worth more in a first meeting than any deck.

There’s a second effect that’s easy to miss. When a company here gets its due, the founder three towns over sees it and quietly recalculates what’s possible from where she’s sitting. That’s how a place starts producing more of them. Not from a program. From proof.

So, we’re going to do the talking. Over the next several weeks, Keystone Innovation Collaborative is publishing lists of Pennsylvania companies worth watching, sector by sector:

• Health and life sciences

• Advanced manufacturing

• Agricultural technology

• Energy technology

• Robotics and AI

Names, founders and the towns they’re building in. Some of those towns you’d expect. A lot of them you wouldn’t.

And if you’re building something here, tell us. We’d rather hear it from you now than find you a year from now.

If we want outside capital and national customers to look this way, somebody here has to say it loudly and then keep saying it. What’s being built in Pennsylvania is worth the trip.

The companies above aren’t unusual. Pennsylvania has been turning them out for a century, in bakeries and machine shops and stables and, at least once, on a base in Afghanistan.

This state has never struggled to build. It has struggled to be heard. That’s the work in front of us.


Martin Fedorko is managing partner of White Rose Ventures, a York-based venture capital firm focused on fueling early-stage innovation, and interim executive director of the Keystone Innovation Collaborative.

Executive Insights is a recurring feature from biznewsPA. It provides local business executives and leaders a platform for sharing advice and perspective with the business community of Central Pennsylvania. If you are interested in contributing an executive insight, email [email protected].

Share:

Gladly Sponsored By:

The main tool we use for the BizNewsPA newsletter is ActiveCampaign.

ActiveCampaign helps us manage our subscribers, build the newsletter, and schedule it for our bright and early release time.

If you think ActiveCampaign can help you and your business, click here.

More Central PA News

Manufacturing

Packaging firm laying off workers after listing Lancaster plant for sale

Nearly two months after putting its Lancaster city complex up for sale, an Illinois-based packaging company has officially announced it is closing the facility and laying off workers. In a WARN notice sent Tuesday to state and local officials, the company, J.L. Clark, attributed the decision to “current market conditions.” Layoffs for the plant’s 34 […]

To access this post, you must purchase biznewsPA Subscription or biznewsPA Team Subscriptions.

Read More »
Education

County leader ‘very optimistic’ about Mont Alto transfer

So far this fall, Penn State trustees have approved sales of three branch campuses that the university plans to close at the end of the current academic year. Waiting in the wings is Penn State Mont Alto, a 106-acre campus about 10 miles southeast of Chambersburg. Leaders in Franklin County expect the property will eventually […]

To access this post, you must purchase biznewsPA Subscription or biznewsPA Team Subscriptions.

Read More »
Manufacturing

Defense firm pouring $300M into Berks County foundry

A defense contractor backed by more than $2 billion in public and private financing has scooped up a Berks County foundry where it plans to expand production of submarine parts. Torrance, California-based manufacturer Hadrian paid $9.4 million for the roughly 260,000-square-foot plant, which had been owned by Pittsburgh-based FerroWorks, according to county deed records. Doing […]

To access this post, you must purchase biznewsPA Subscription or biznewsPA Team Subscriptions.

Read More »
Retail

Food hall bets on video game to boost business, engagement

Before they sampled the food at Franklin Street Social, the 20-something game developers from Made In House were impressed by what they saw. The Red Lion food hall is decorated in a colorful style reminiscent of a New York City subway station and features a slide and children’s playhouse, as well as an array of […]

To access this post, you must purchase biznewsPA Subscription or biznewsPA Team Subscriptions.

Read More »
Education

‘So much potential’: York College to buy Penn State York campus

Leaders at York College fully expected to play some role in the future of Penn State York, one of seven branch campuses that Penn State is closing next year. They just didn’t expect to own it, according to York College president Thomas Burns, who said the school initially expected to be a tenant Given the […]

To access this post, you must purchase biznewsPA Subscription or biznewsPA Team Subscriptions.

Read More »
Transportation

Dulles flights reportedly returning to Lancaster

Is United Airlines adding daily service between Lancaster Airport and Washington Dulles International Airport in Northern Virginia? Trade publication Airline Geeks reported the planned addition of the twice-daily flights in a post Monday, citing a United spokesperson. In addition, nonstop flights between Lancaster and Dulles are now available for booking on the United website. Efforts […]

To access this post, you must purchase biznewsPA Subscription or biznewsPA Team Subscriptions.

Read More »