Subscribe to our newsletters!

You can’t redistribute what hasn’t been produced

Column by Richard Randall

I feel the need to repeat something I know I’ve said before: All national wealth is created by commercial activity. In other words, all wealth is created by business. By business I mean anything from an individual entrepreneur to a major corporation. It seems today that a lot of people with anti-business attitudes don’t understand that.

Wealth is created when value is added. This happens when individuals or businesses create products or services that others are willing to exchange for.

Money itself is not wealth. It is just a means of exchange. When government prints money, it doesn’t create wealth. In fact, if more money is added to the economic system without concurrently increasing the production of wealth by commercial activity, the value of all the money in the system declines. That’s what happens in banana republics with runaway inflation.

Richard Randall

Government doesn’t create wealth when it borrows money. When the government borrows money, it commits future tax receipts to pay the debt. It commits that part of the future wealth created by individuals and businesses though commercial activity which it can collect via taxation. Government borrowing is a redistribution of wealth.

Taxation and redistribution don’t create wealth. They move existing wealth around. Redistribution can serve purposes like reducing inequality or funding public goods, but it doesn’t by itself make the economic pie bigger. All the government does is redistribute slices of that pie.

Government does have a role in helping businesses prosper, by way of sensible regulations, and by supporting the creation of infrastructure. Government can support education and research, which are exploited by businesses and individuals. But don’t forget it is commercial activity that pays for the infrastructure, the research and the education support.

I’ve seen some claims lately that nonprofit charitable organizations are adding value to the economy, in other words creating wealth. In general, charitable organizations don’t create wealth; they consume and redistribute it. That isn’t to take anything away from the importance of charitable organizations. They do amazing, important things, and they provide jobs for many people. But in almost every case, it is all funded with wealth created by commercial activity, which is then donated to these organizations.

Some charitable organizations create parallel organizations to engage in “social entrepreneurship”- wealth building via business activity – which they can exploit to reduce their dependence on fundraising. Those are an exception to the rule.

Why don’t most people understand the issue of wealth creation? I think it’s because it isn’t taught in school, it doesn’t make a compelling story for journalists, and business leaders fail to take any part in educating the public.

You don’t have to look too hard to find articles, op-ed columns, and social media posts railing about the evils of greedy businesses or business owners or CEOs, as if they are the cause of people’s economic problems. We need more knowledgeable people in business speaking up about this issue of wealth creation, getting people to understand where all of our wealth as people and as a nation is created.


Richard Randall is founder and president of management consulting firm New Level Advisors in Springettsbury Township, York County. Email him at [email protected].

Executives Insights is a recurring feature from biznewsPA that provides local business executives and leaders a platform for sharing advice and perspective with the business community of Central Pennsylvania. If you are interested in contributing an executive insight, email [email protected].

Column by Richard Randall

I feel the need to repeat something I know I’ve said before: All national wealth is created by commercial activity. In other words, all wealth is created by business. By business I mean anything from an individual entrepreneur to a major corporation. It seems today that a lot of people with anti-business attitudes don’t understand that.

Wealth is created when value is added. This happens when individuals or businesses create products or services that others are willing to exchange for.

Money itself is not wealth. It is just a means of exchange. When government prints money, it doesn’t create wealth. In fact, if more money is added to the economic system without concurrently increasing the production of wealth by commercial activity, the value of all the money in the system declines. That’s what happens in banana republics with runaway inflation.

Richard Randall

Government doesn’t create wealth when it borrows money. When the government borrows money, it commits future tax receipts to pay the debt. It commits that part of the future wealth created by individuals and businesses though commercial activity which it can collect via taxation. Government borrowing is a redistribution of wealth.

Taxation and redistribution don’t create wealth. They move existing wealth around. Redistribution can serve purposes like reducing inequality or funding public goods, but it doesn’t by itself make the economic pie bigger. All the government does is redistribute slices of that pie.

Government does have a role in helping businesses prosper, by way of sensible regulations, and by supporting the creation of infrastructure. Government can support education and research, which are exploited by businesses and individuals. But don’t forget it is commercial activity that pays for the infrastructure, the research and the education support.

I’ve seen some claims lately that nonprofit charitable organizations are adding value to the economy, in other words creating wealth. In general, charitable organizations don’t create wealth; they consume and redistribute it. That isn’t to take anything away from the importance of charitable organizations. They do amazing, important things, and they provide jobs for many people. But in almost every case, it is all funded with wealth created by commercial activity, which is then donated to these organizations.

Some charitable organizations create parallel organizations to engage in “social entrepreneurship”- wealth building via business activity – which they can exploit to reduce their dependence on fundraising. Those are an exception to the rule.

Why don’t most people understand the issue of wealth creation? I think it’s because it isn’t taught in school, it doesn’t make a compelling story for journalists, and business leaders fail to take any part in educating the public.

You don’t have to look too hard to find articles, op-ed columns, and social media posts railing about the evils of greedy businesses or business owners or CEOs, as if they are the cause of people’s economic problems. We need more knowledgeable people in business speaking up about this issue of wealth creation, getting people to understand where all of our wealth as people and as a nation is created.


Richard Randall is founder and president of management consulting firm New Level Advisors in Springettsbury Township, York County. Email him at [email protected].

Executives Insights is a recurring feature from biznewsPA that provides local business executives and leaders a platform for sharing advice and perspective with the business community of Central Pennsylvania. If you are interested in contributing an executive insight, email [email protected].

Share:

Gladly Sponsored By:

The main tool we use for the BizNewsPA newsletter is ActiveCampaign.

ActiveCampaign helps us manage our subscribers, build the newsletter, and schedule it for our bright and early release time.

If you think ActiveCampaign can help you and your business, click here.

More Central PA News

Education

‘So much potential’: York College to buy Penn State York campus

Leaders at York College fully expected to play some role in the future of Penn State York, one of seven branch campuses that Penn State is closing next year. They just didn’t expect to own it, according to York College president Thomas Burns, who said the school initially expected to be a tenant Given the […]

To access this post, you must purchase biznewsPA Subscription or biznewsPA Team Subscriptions.

Read More »
Transportation

Dulles flights reportedly returning to Lancaster

Is United Airlines adding daily service between Lancaster Airport and Washington Dulles International Airport in Northern Virginia? Trade publication Airline Geeks reported the planned addition of the twice-daily flights in a post Monday, citing a United spokesperson. In addition, nonstop flights between Lancaster and Dulles are now available for booking on the United website. Efforts […]

To access this post, you must purchase biznewsPA Subscription or biznewsPA Team Subscriptions.

Read More »
Energy

State advocate goes to court over incentives for $1.7B power line

Concerned about the potential impact on homes and businesses, Pennsylvania’s top consumer advocate is stepping up efforts to oppose some of the financial incentives granted to a proposed power line that would run more than half the length of the state. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission signed off on the incentives in July for the […]

To access this post, you must purchase biznewsPA Subscription or biznewsPA Team Subscriptions.

Read More »
Government

Opportunity Zones knock again

The federal government has finalized tracts in Central Pennsylvania where investors can reap tax savings under a tax-abatement program created in 2017. The federal Opportunity Zone program was slated to expire by 2028. It was extended permanently under the signature tax legislation of President Donald Trump’s second term. Last week, federal regulators finalized the map of […]

To access this post, you must purchase biznewsPA Subscription or biznewsPA Team Subscriptions.

Read More »
Construction

Developer forecasts 2027 start to $60M apartment conversion in Harrisburg

More than three years after buying one of Harrisburg’s largest office buildings, New Jersey developer Yasser Helal says he aims to begin a residential conversion starting in early 2027. Helal secured zoning approvals for the $60 million project in early 2024 and has spent the time since then working to line up construction financing from […]

To access this post, you must purchase biznewsPA Subscription or biznewsPA Team Subscriptions.

Read More »
Government

Chamber leader open to compromise on minimum wage

In March, Pennsylvania’s Democratic-controlled House narrowly passed legislation phasing in hikes to the state’s minimum wage. The bill has sat ever since in a committee in the GOP-led Senate. With Democrats poised to take a majority in the Senate and expand their edge in the House, is a minimum-wage hike inevitable following more than a […]

To access this post, you must purchase biznewsPA Subscription or biznewsPA Team Subscriptions.

Read More »